Because every reading of Revelation is assembled the same way, by pulling pieces out of half a dozen other books as if one author wrote all of them, and nothing in that method can tell you when you've done it wrong. The camps can't settle it because there's no test available to settle it with. And the bible makes the problem worse, because it doesn't speak with one voice in the first place.
Here's what goes unpreached.
The disagreement isn't about details
Some Christians say all of it already happened, in the first century, when Jerusalem fell and the temple came down. Others say none of it has happened yet, and that believers will be taken out before a seven-year stretch of trouble begins.
Whether the event has already taken place isn't a detail. It's the whole question. They can't both be reading the same plain meaning off the page, and every one of them says that's exactly what they're doing.
How a chart gets built
No end-times chart comes out of Revelation alone. Here's how one gets put together.
A horn in Daniel becomes a person. That person is matched to a lawless figure from a letter written to a congregation in Greece. He's given the name antichrist, borrowed from two short letters that never describe him, then installed as the beast of Revelation, a book written by someone else, later, somewhere else. Daniel supplies a seven-year clock. Thessalonians supplies believers being taken up. Ezekiel supplies an invading army.
That's several books, written centuries apart in different countries by writers who never read each other. The chart treats them as chapters of one document by one author who spread a single picture across a thousand years. The camp that says it all happened in the first century does the same thing from the other end, reading Revelation through the gospel sayings about the temple.
Nobody argues for that assumption. It's just in place before the first verse gets read, doing all the work.
Check the assumption
You can test it with your own bible.
Numbers 23:19, NRSVue:
God is not a human being, that he should lie, or a mortal, that he should change his mind. Has he promised, and will he not do it? Has he spoken, and will he not fulfill it?
That's the verse people reach for when they want to say a promise can't be broken. Now open Exodus 32, where god tells Moses to leave him alone so he can destroy the people. Moses pushes back, tells him to turn from his anger, reminds him of what he swore to Abraham, Isaac and Israel. Then verse 14:
And the LORD changed his mind about the disaster that he planned to bring on his people.
So the contradiction, stated outright. One writer says god doesn't change his mind. Another writer says he did, because a man argued with him. Genesis 18 has Abraham doing the same thing over Sodom, bargaining the number down from fifty to ten.
I've laid these passages side by side in comment threads for people who insisted I was jumping around the bible stringing together verses that had nothing to do with each other. The objection only works if the book speaks with one voice, and these passages show it doesn't. The contradiction is there because it's a collection, and the writers in it didn't share one picture of their god.
"Scripture interprets scripture"
Here's the answer you'll get, in its defenders' terms. Scripture interprets scripture. The unity of the bible isn't smuggled in, it's a principle the church has held for centuries, and it's what allows a library to be taught as one message. Numbers 23 gives the rule that god's purposes stand. Exodus 32 shows him dealing with people inside time, where a warning is issued so they'll turn, and when they turn, the warning has done its job.
Grant all of it, and look at what just happened. The reader decided before reading that the passages had to fit, and then built the reading that makes them fit. Exodus 32:14 doesn't say a warning did its job. It says he changed his mind about a disaster he planned. That reconciliation was laid on top of the text to protect a conclusion.
That's the same procedure that builds the end-times chart. Decide it must fit, then make it fit. If you accept it for Numbers and Exodus, you can't object when the next camp uses it to assemble a timeline you think is nonsense, because nothing in the method says where to stop. That's why the camps can't settle anything. Each one is using the only tool available, and the tool agrees with whoever's holding it.
The teacher who was supposed to settle it
The text does promise a way out of this. 1 John 2:27, NRSVue:
As for you, the anointing that you received from him abides in you, so you do not need anyone to teach you. But as his anointing teaches you about all things and is true and is not a lie, and just as it has taught you, abide in him.
Take it as written. A believer with that anointing doesn't need a human teacher, and what it teaches is true. So believers who have it should land in the same place on Revelation. They don't. The Catholic, the Baptist, the Adventist and the Pentecostal all say the spirit guides them, and they come out with different endings. The splits follow the denomination and the study bible in the house, not anything in the text.
The usual reply is that 1 John was written to a congregation being pulled away by other teachers, and was never a ban on teaching. Fine. Whatever the arrangement, two believers with the same spirit and different teachers end up with incompatible schedules, and each one is certain. Whatever's producing the certainty isn't producing the content.
Ask anyone where they first saw the chart. They'll name a pastor, a paperback, a radio program or a Sunday school class. Nobody names the anointing.
What the text won't support
It won't support any Christian who says they're just reading what it says about the end. Every chart is somebody's arrangement of pieces from books that were never written to fit together, and nobody can show their arrangement is the right one. So there's no more reason to trust the reading you were raised in than the one taught at the church down the street.
And it won't support the idea that the bible is one reliable account that only needs careful reading. A book that says its god doesn't change his mind, and then records him changing it, has already told you what kind of book it is. Christians can't agree on Revelation because they're asking a collection of different writers to be one voice, and it isn't one.
If you want more passages like these, all checkable in your own bible, the free guide Twelve Verses Your Church Skipped has twelve of them. And if you'd rather have Revelation's imagery turned into a story, my novel The War Against The End of Days is built out of it and reworked from the ground up.