Four riders who show up in eight verses of Revelation 6 and nowhere else in the bible. Three of them are never named. And the picture they ride out of was already sitting in the collection, twice over, before Revelation was written.
Here's what goes unpreached. The horsemen aren't a preview of anything. They're stock imagery, assembled out of parts the writer's own scriptures had already printed, and both sources are still in the book where anybody can go look them up.
What the page actually hands you
Then I saw the Lamb break one of the seven seals, and I heard one of the four living creatures call out, as with a voice of thunder, "Come!" I looked, and there was a white horse! Its rider had a bow; a crown was given to him, and he came out conquering and to conquer.
— Revelation 6:1–2, NRSVue
A bow and a crown, and no name.
The second rider comes out on a bright red horse, gets permission to take peace from the earth so people will slaughter each other, and is handed a great sword. No name there either. The third rides a black horse and holds a pair of scales, and then a voice sets prices: a quart of wheat for a day's pay, three quarts of barley for a day's pay, and don't damage the olive oil and the wine. Read that twice, because it isn't famine. There's food. A day of work buys a day of bread and nothing past it, and two commodities get protected by name.
Then the fourth, and this is the one everything else turns on.
I looked, and there was a pale green horse! Its rider's name was Death, and Hades followed with him; they were given authority over a fourth of the earth, to kill with sword, famine, and pestilence and by the wild animals of the earth.
— Revelation 6:8, NRSVue
One rider gets a name, and the name is Death. Conquest, War, Famine and Pestilence, the four names printed on every chart and poster and album cover, are not on the page. Readers supplied them. And you can see where three came from: sword, famine and pestilence all sit in verse 8, as the list of ways the fourth rider kills. The tradition lifted one rider's equipment and handed a piece of it to each of the others.
The riders came out of a picture the collection had already drawn twice
Open Zechariah. Chapter 1 has a man on a red horse standing among the myrtle trees, with more horses behind him, sent out to go through the earth and report back on what they found. Chapter 6 runs the same idea tighter: four chariots come out from between two mountains, the first with red horses, the second black, the third white, the fourth dappled, and they go out to the four winds.
Colored horses. Four of them. Sent across the earth on an errand from god. That's Revelation 6 before Revelation existed.
Now open Ezekiel 14 and read to the end of the chapter. God itemizes four judgments and sends them against a city together: the sword, famine, wild animals, and disease. Your edition may print that last one as plague or as pestilence, and it's the same set either way. Now read verse 8 again — sword, famine, pestilence, wild animals.
Same four. Same order of thought. So the writer of Revelation didn't receive a new list. He took the one his own scriptures had already published and mounted it on Zechariah's horses.
Which is what this god's judgments always look like
That list was lying around because it's the only list this god has ever worked from.
If Christians knew their book, they'd recognize the god in it as a storm deity who fights. Nahum has him showing his power in the whirlwind and the storm, drying up rivers and melting the hills. Second Samuel 22 has smoke pouring from his nostrils while he rides on the wind, shooting lightning to scatter an army. Storm, plague, famine, sword, wild animals: that's the toolkit, in Egypt and in the prophets, and it's what rides out when the seals get opened.
Which puts the modern reader in an awkward spot. The people most certain the horsemen are still coming are usually the same people who get uncomfortable when somebody says god sent a particular tornado. So which is it? If this god issues his verdicts through weather and disease and hunger and armies, then he's doing it now or he never did it.
Run the excuses
The first one is about scale. The horsemen are still ahead of us, the argument goes, and what will identify them is the size of what they do: conquest, war, hunger and plague running worldwide and all at once, in a way no earlier century was capable of.
Scale isn't in the passage. The text gives the fourth rider a fourth of the earth, a smaller share than several ordinary epidemics have already taken out of the populations they reached. Nothing in those eight verses says worldwide, or simultaneous, or unprecedented. Those words get added by the person doing the matching, because without them the passage describes a normal bad century.
The second excuse grants the Zechariah and Ezekiel material and tries to turn it around. The resemblance is deliberate, it says, and that's evidence of one author standing behind both books, reusing his own imagery so his people would know it when they saw it again.
Fine. Take it. It doesn't matter, because your own text still says what it says. If chapter 6 is a deliberate callback to judgments Ezekiel itemized and horses Zechariah saw, then what a reader is holding is a picture of the standard judgment set, drawn in borrowed lines. What it isn't is an announcement of four specific events still missing from history.
What that does to the newspaper reading
The horsemen get matched to headlines every decade or so. The white rider is whichever leader is rising, the red one is whichever war just started, the black is the inflation number, and the pale one is whatever illness is on the news that month. That works because the four categories are the four broadest categories of human catastrophe available. Conquest, war, hunger, death. Name a century that didn't supply all four. Name a decade. The match rate is a hundred percent, which sounds impressive until you notice that a hundred percent is what a claim that can't miss produces every single time.
And here's the part that closes it. These riders are released by seals opening on a scroll, in a vision, in a letter written to congregations living under an empire that ran on conquest, requisitioned grain, and death. Those people weren't waiting on a forecast. They needed a picture of the thing already sitting on top of them, drawn in imagery their own scriptures had trained them to read. They got one, and it's been read as a schedule ever since.
What the text will not support
It won't support four named riders, because three of them have no name.
It won't support a famine at the third seal, because the voice in that scene prices grain and then protects the oil and the wine.
It won't support anything new being disclosed, because the horses were in Zechariah and the four judgments were in Ezekiel.
And it won't support a countdown running into your century, because the book opens by telling the people holding it that all of this must happen soon.
Eight verses, with one name in them. Everything else on the poster got added by the people looking at it. Open your bible and check me.
There are eleven more passages like this one in the free guide, Twelve Verses Your Church Skipped.
And if you want the riders as a story instead of an argument, I wrote one of those. The War Against The End of Days is a novel built out of Revelation's images rather than a rendering of them, and it opens with a rider on a white horse.